The reviews you don’t answer: the channel speaking to your next guests

Book a consultation
15 Novembre 2026 · 2 min read
Dylan Succi
Dylan Succi
Author

Before booking, almost everyone reads the reviews. But there is one part of the profile that gets read more carefully than the rest: your replies. A property that only answers the compliments, always with the same copied-and-pasted line, is saying something. And the person deciding whether to spend a hundred euros a night notices it.

The reply is the only part of the profile you write

Guests write the reviews. You write the replies: the only space where you can speak directly to the person evaluating you, showing how you treat people. The most revealing moment is the reply to a negative review — that is where future guests understand what happens when something goes wrong.

The three replies that really matter

  • To the positive review: one true detail of the stay, not a template. Not “thank you for your feedback”, but “so glad the breakfast with the local bakery’s pastries stuck with you”.
  • To the negative review: say thanks, state the facts without getting defensive, explain what you fixed. Never argue in public: the argument is always won in private.
  • To the mixed review: pick up the point they praised and acknowledge the critical one. These are often the most useful, because they describe the property as it really is.

Timing counts almost as much as wording

A reply arriving two months later weighs as much as no reply. Block half an hour a week, same day every week, and answer everything that came in. Answer the negative ones first: calmly, but fast.

Where to start today

Open your profile and look at it with a guest’s eyes: how many reviews are sitting unanswered? How many of your replies are identical to each other? The first month you don’t need poetry — you need presence. A property that replies is a property that proves it is run by people, and that is exactly what the person about to book is looking for.